The Little Girl & Rain on the Roof

Given: Emotions in Column A are to be matched with situations in Column B.

Concept: Understanding Kezia's emotional responses to different situations involving her father.

Matching:

1. Fear or terror → (iii) father comes home, (iv) speaking to father, (v) going to bed when alone at home

2. Glad sense of relief → (ii) noise of the carriage grows fainter

3. A "funny" feeling, perhaps of understanding → (i) father comes into her room to give her a goodbye kiss, (vi) father comforts her and falls asleep, (vii) father stretched out on the sofa, snoring

Explanation: Kezia was terrified of her father's presence and voice, so situations involving him directly caused fear. When he left, she felt relieved. Towards the end, when she saw her father's exhaustion and felt his warmth, she began to understand him — giving rise to a "funny" feeling of empathy.

Given: The story describes Kezia's relationship with her father.

Answer: Kezia was afraid of her father because he was a large, stern, and authoritative man. He rarely spoke to her gently; instead, he spoke in a loud, commanding voice. He seemed cold and distant, and whenever Kezia was in his presence, she would stammer and feel nervous. His habit of ordering her around and his strict manner made her feel that he was someone to be feared rather than loved.

Given: The story 'The Little Girl' by Katherine Mansfield.

Answer: Kezia's family consisted of four members:
1. Kezia — the little girl, the central character.
2. Her father — a strict, authoritative man.
3. Her mother — who was often unwell and rested in the afternoons.
4. Her grandmother — a kind and understanding woman who encouraged Kezia to bond with her father.

Given: The story describes the father's daily routine.

(i) Before going to his office:
Every morning, Kezia's father would come to her room and give her a goodbye kiss. This was a brief, formal interaction that filled Kezia with fear rather than warmth.

(ii) After coming back from his office:
After returning from work, he would ask for his tea to be brought to him and then read the newspaper. He would then have his evening meal and go to bed early. He was tired and had no time or energy to interact with Kezia.

(iii) On Sundays:
On Sundays, Kezia's father would stretch out on the sofa and sleep, snoring loudly. He seemed completely exhausted and spent his day of rest sleeping, which made him appear even more distant and unapproachable to Kezia.

Given: The role of the grandmother in Kezia's life.

Answer: Kezia's grandmother played an important role in trying to bridge the gap between Kezia and her father. She encouraged Kezia to go into the drawing room and talk to her father on Sunday afternoons when he was resting. She also suggested that Kezia make a pin-cushion as a birthday gift for her father, so that Kezia could show her love and affection for him. Through these small gestures, the grandmother tried to help Kezia overcome her fear and develop a closer relationship with her father.

Given: The incident of the pin-cushion in the story.

Introduction: Kezia genuinely wanted to please her father on his birthday and made a sincere effort to do so. However, her good intentions led to an outcome that angered him greatly.

Development: Kezia's grandmother suggested that she make a pin-cushion as a birthday gift for her father. Kezia worked hard to sew the cushion, but she needed something to stuff it with. She found some papers in her parents' bedroom and tore them up to use as stuffing, not realising what they were. Unfortunately, the papers turned out to be an important speech that her father had carefully prepared.

Consequence: When her father discovered that his speech had been destroyed, he was furious. He called Kezia to the drawing room and punished her by hitting her palms with a ruler. Kezia was devastated — she had only wanted to make him happy, but her innocent mistake had caused the opposite effect.

Conclusion: This incident deepened Kezia's fear of her father and made her feel that no matter what she did, she could never please him. It highlights the lack of communication and understanding between the two.

Given: The contrast between Mr Macdonald and Kezia's father.

Introduction: After being punished by her father, Kezia began to observe the family next door — the MacDonalds — and realised that not all fathers were the same.

Mr Macdonald as a father: Mr Macdonald was a warm, playful, and affectionate father. Kezia would watch him playing games with his five children in the garden. He would run, laugh, and roll about on the grass with them. He was full of energy and joy when he was with his children. He was approachable, fun-loving, and emotionally available for his family.

Contrast with Kezia's father: Kezia's father, on the other hand, was stern, distant, and authoritative. He rarely played with Kezia or showed her affection. He was always tired after work and spent his free time sleeping. He communicated with Kezia mostly through commands and rarely smiled at her. His large physical presence and loud voice made Kezia feel afraid rather than loved.

Conclusion: The contrast between the two fathers made Kezia realise that fatherhood could be expressed in different ways. While Mr Macdonald expressed his love openly and joyfully, Kezia's father's love was hidden beneath layers of exhaustion, responsibility, and an inability to express emotions — something Kezia only begins to understand later.

Given: The concluding part of the story where Kezia's perception of her father changes.

Introduction: Throughout the story, Kezia sees her father only as a frightening authority figure. However, a turning point comes when she has a nightmare and her father comforts her.

The Turning Point: One night, while Kezia's mother was in the hospital and her grandmother was away, Kezia had a terrible nightmare. She woke up screaming. Her father came to her room, comforted her, and took her to his own bed so she would not be afraid. He lay beside her and told her to rub her feet against his legs to warm herself.

Kezia's Realisation: As Kezia lay next to her father, she felt his warmth and protection. She noticed how tired he was — he fell asleep almost immediately. She began to think about how hard he worked all day to provide for the family, and how little time he had left for himself or for her. She realised that he was not a cold or cruel man, but simply an exhausted human being carrying many responsibilities.

Conclusion: This experience filled Kezia with a new feeling — not fear, but sympathy and understanding. She began to see her father not just as an authority figure, but as a tired, hardworking man who loved her in his own way. She whispered, "What a hard life he has," showing that she had grown in emotional maturity and empathy.

Given: Synonyms for happiness: glad, happy, pleased, delighted, thrilled, overjoyed. Clues are given in brackets.

Concept: Each synonym expresses a different degree or type of happiness.

(i) She was thrilled by the news of her brother's wedding. *(very pleased — thrilled suggests excitement and great pleasure)*

(ii) I was delighted to be invited to the party. *(extremely pleased and excited about)*

(iii) She was overjoyed at the birth of her granddaughter. *(extremely happy — overjoyed is the strongest expression of happiness)*

(iv) The coach was pleased with his performance. *(satisfied about — pleased is moderate and formal)*

(v) She was very happy with her results. *(happy about something that has happened — a general, warm feeling of satisfaction)*

Given: The word 'big' is used in different contexts. We must find its meaning in each sentence.

Concept: The word 'big' is polysemous — it has multiple meanings depending on context.

(i) You are a big girl now. → older / grown-up *(already done as example)*

(ii) Today you are going to take the biggest decision of your career. → most important / significant

(iii) Their project is full of big ideas. → ambitious / grand / innovative

(iv) Cricket is a big game in our country. → popular / widely followed

(v) I am a big fan of Lata Mangeshkar. → great / enthusiastic / devoted

(vi) You have to cook a bit more as my friend is a big eater. → someone who eats a lot / heavy eater

(vii) What a big heart you've got, Father dear. → generous / kind / large-hearted

Given: Sentences containing verbs of reporting.

Concept: A verb of reporting is used to quote or report what someone said, thought, asked, or felt.

The verbs of reporting in each sentence are:

(i) He says he will enjoy the ride.

(ii) Father mentioned that he was going on a holiday.

(iii) No one told us that the shop was closed.

(iv) He answered that the price would go up.

(v) I wondered why he was screaming.

(vi) Ben told her to wake him up.

(vii) Ratan apologised for coming late to the party.

Given: A box of reporting verbs: were complaining, shouted, replied, remarked, ordered, suggested.

Concept: Each reporting verb conveys a specific manner of speaking or communicating.

(i) "I am not afraid," replied the woman.
*(replied — she is responding to something said to her)*

(ii) "Leave me alone," my mother shouted.
*(shouted — the exclamatory tone suggests a raised voice)*

(iii) The children were complaining that the roads were crowded and noisy.
*(were complaining — expressing dissatisfaction)*

(iv) "Perhaps he isn't a bad sort of a chap after all," remarked the master.
*(remarked — a casual, observational comment)*

(v) "Let's go and look at the school ground," suggested the sports teacher.
*(suggested — proposing an idea)*

(vi) The traffic police ordered all the passers-by to keep off the road.
*(ordered — giving a command with authority)*

Discussion Points:

Yes, the characters in this story are very relatable to Indian families as well. In many Indian households, fathers are the primary breadwinners and often come home tired after long hours of work. Like Kezia's father, they may appear strict and distant, not because they do not love their children, but because they are burdened with responsibilities and do not always know how to express their emotions.

Mothers in India, too, are often busy managing the household and may sometimes be unwell or preoccupied, leaving children to fend for themselves emotionally.

Grandmothers in Indian families, much like Kezia's grandmother, are typically warm, nurturing, and act as a bridge between children and their parents. They often encourage children to respect and understand their parents.

Thus, while the story is set in a Western context, its emotional core is universal and deeply relevant to Indian family dynamics.

Discussion Points:

Was he right to punish her?
Kezia's father punished her for tearing up his important speech papers. While his anger was understandable — the papers were significant — the punishment (hitting her palms with a ruler) was perhaps too harsh for a small child who had acted out of innocent ignorance, not malice. A gentler explanation would have been more appropriate.

What kind of person was he?
Kezia's father was a complex character. He was:
- Hard-working and responsible — he worked long hours to provide for his family.
- Strict and undemonstrative — he rarely showed affection openly.
- Short-tempered — he reacted harshly to Kezia's mistake.
- A disciplinarian — he believed in rules and order.
- Loving (in his own way) — at the end, he comforts Kezia during her nightmare, showing that he does care for her.

He was not unkind at heart, but his inability to express love made him appear cold and frightening to his daughter.

Note to students: This is a personal writing task. Below is a model answer that you may adapt based on your own experience.

---

My Relationship with My Parents

As a young child, I sometimes found my parents strict and difficult to understand, much like Kezia felt about her father. My father, too, would come home tired from work and had little time to play or talk. I often felt that he did not understand me, and I was sometimes afraid to share my problems with him.

However, as I have grown older, my perception has changed considerably. I now realise how hard both my parents work to give me a comfortable life. The long hours, the responsibilities, and the sacrifices they make are things I was too young to appreciate before. I see now that their strictness came from love and a desire to see me succeed.

I have also noticed that my parents have become more open to listening to me as I have matured. They ask for my opinions and treat me more as an equal. This mutual respect has strengthened our relationship.

To build an even better relationship, I would like to spend more quality time with my parents — talking, sharing my thoughts, and listening to their experiences. I believe that open communication, patience, and gratitude are the keys to a strong and understanding family bond.

Given: Phrases from the poem 'Rain on the Roof' by Coates Kinney.

(i) humid shadows:
This phrase refers to the dark, moisture-laden clouds that gather in the sky before it rains. 'Humid' suggests dampness and moisture, while 'shadows' refers to the darkness cast by the clouds. Together, the phrase creates an image of a cloudy, overcast sky heavy with rain.

(ii) starry spheres:
This phrase refers to the sky filled with stars. 'Spheres' is a poetic word for the heavens or the sky. The phrase suggests the vast, star-studded night sky that is now hidden behind rain clouds.

(iii) what a bliss:
This is an exclamation of pure joy and happiness. The poet feels that lying in a cosy bed and listening to the patter of rain on the roof is an experience of complete bliss — a deeply satisfying and peaceful pleasure.

(iv) a thousand dreamy fancies into busy being start:
This phrase means that the sound of the rain triggers countless daydreams and imaginative thoughts in the poet's mind. The rain acts as a stimulus that sets his imagination working actively, bringing to life many pleasant, dreamy ideas and memories.

(v) a thousand recollections weave their air-threads into woof:
This phrase means that the rain brings back a flood of memories. Just as threads are woven together to form cloth (woof = weft, the threads woven across a loom), the poet's recollections interweave with each other to form a rich tapestry of memories. The memories are described as 'air-threads' because they are delicate, intangible, and dreamlike.

Given: The poem 'Rain on the Roof' by Coates Kinney.

Answer: When it rains, the poet likes to lie in his cosy bed and listen to the soft patter of the raindrops falling on the wooden roof (shingles) of his cottage. He finds great pleasure and comfort in pressing his head against his pillow and listening to the music of the rain. The sound of the rain fills his mind with a thousand dreamy fancies and brings back fond memories of the past, especially of his mother. He considers this experience to be one of the greatest joys in life.

Given: The poem 'Rain on the Roof' by Coates Kinney.

The Single Major Memory: The single most important memory that comes to the poet when he hears the rain is that of his mother. He remembers how his mother used to look lovingly at her children as they slept. He recalls her tender, caring gaze — the image of her looking down at her sleeping children with love and affection.

The "Darling Dreamers": The "darling dreamers" refers to the poet and his siblings — the children who used to sleep peacefully while their mother watched over them. They are called 'darling dreamers' because they were the beloved children, lost in their innocent dreams, under the watchful and loving eyes of their mother. The phrase is filled with nostalgia and tenderness.

Given: The poem 'Rain on the Roof' by Coates Kinney.

Answer: No, the poet is not a child anymore. The poem is written from the perspective of an adult who is lying in his bed listening to the rain and reminiscing about the past. The use of the word 'recollections' and the way he looks back at his childhood memories make it clear that he is now grown up.

His mother is no longer alive. The poet refers to her in the past tense — "she used to" look at her children — which suggests that she has passed away. The memory of his mother is described with deep longing and nostalgia, indicating that she is no longer with him. The rain brings back these bittersweet memories of a mother who is gone but not forgotten.

Note: This is a personal response question. Students are expected to answer from their own experience. Below is a model answer.

Model Answer: Yes, when I was a young child, my mother would tuck me in every night before I went to sleep. She would pull the blanket over me, make sure I was comfortable, and sometimes tell me a story or sing a lullaby. Her presence made me feel safe and loved. Reading this poem brings back those warm memories, and I can understand why the poet treasures the memory of his mother so deeply. Those moments of care and tenderness are among the most precious memories of childhood.

Note: This is a personal response question. Below is a model answer.

Model Answer: Yes, I love the rain, especially when it rains steadily and heavily. When it rains, I like to sit near the window and watch the raindrops fall. Sometimes I make a cup of hot tea and read a book, listening to the sound of the rain in the background. Like the poet, I find the sound of rain on the roof very soothing and peaceful. It makes me feel relaxed and sometimes brings back happy memories of childhood — playing in the rain, making paper boats, and splashing in puddles. Rain has a magical quality that slows everything down and makes the world feel quieter and more beautiful.

Given: A reflective question about how different people and animals experience rain.

Answer: No, not everybody has the luxury of a cosy bed to lie in when it rains. While the poet enjoys the comfort of his warm bed and the music of the rain, many people and creatures face hardship during the same rain.

Homeless people have no shelter and are forced to huddle under bridges, in doorways, or beneath trees, getting wet and cold.

Street vendors and daily wage workers must continue working in the rain or lose their income for the day. They often have only a thin plastic sheet or a tarpaulin for protection.

Farmers may welcome the rain for their crops, but heavy rain can also destroy their fields and flood their homes.

Stray animals like dogs and cats seek shelter under parked vehicles, in drains, or under staircases. Birds huddle together on branches or in nests.

Children in slums often live in homes with leaking roofs, where rain means discomfort rather than pleasure.

This reflection reminds us that the same rain that brings joy and poetry to some brings hardship and suffering to others. It is important to be grateful for our comforts and to be empathetic towards those who are less fortunate.